Jim Jr. has been serving the Zanesville area as an Independent Agent for the last 26 years. He is a graduate of West Muskingum High School and received his Bachelors of Business degree from Ohio University. Jim began his insurance career in July of 1990 and began working at the McInturf Insurance Agency in November of the same year. He then purchased the business in 2014. In 2016, Jim merged his agency with Fulmer Insurance Services to create the McInturf-Fulmer Insurance Group. Jim is on the board of directors for the Zanesville Muskingum County Chamber of Commerce, a current board member for Goodwill Industries, a member of the Chairman’s Advisory Committee at Medical Benefits Mutual, and was a Past President for the Zanesville Association of Life Underwriters. He has served on many boards in the community, including the Muskingum Family YMCA, United Way of Muskingum, Perry, and Morgan Counties, and the Arsenal Soccer Club. Jim is a former Varsity head coach for the West Muskingum High School boys’ and girls’ soccer teams and a member of Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church. Jim and his wife, Jennifer, currently live in Zanesville and have three children, Sarah, Libby, and Leah. In his free time, Jim enjoys exercising and watching Ohio sports, most notably THE Ohio State Buckeyes.
Mike Fulmer, CLCS, is a graduate of West Muskingum High School and Ohio University. Mike began his insurance career with Monumental Life Insurance in 2006 focusing mainly on life insurance. In 2007 he joined the family business and expanded his focus into auto, home, farm and business insurance. In 2011 Mike obtained his Commercial Lines Coverage Specialist (CLCS) designation and completed State Auto's prestigious Pacesetter program. Mike lends his expertise to the Muskingum County Business Incubator and Small Business Development Center advising new entrepreneurs on the potential risks of their new business ventures. Mike is a member of the Muskingum Valley Vineyard Church. Mike has served on many boards previously, including the American Cancer Society, Zanesville-Muskingum Chamber of Commerce and Taylor McHenry foundation. Mike currently serves as a board member with both the Zanesville Jaycees and the Jaycees Golf Course.
Mike currently resides in Zanesville with his wife Katie and their two dogs, Rowdy and Levi. Mike’s hobbies including running, golfing and The Ohio State University football and basketball. Mike enjoys working with clients to develop a comprehensive insurance plan that fits their needs. He firmly believes that "Your Best Policy is a Good Agent!"
Sarah Linn is a graduate of West Muskingum High School and Ohio University. Sarah started working for our agency in 2014. Sarah specializes in Health, Life, Accident and Disability Insurance, in particular assisting clients with the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare), as she is licensed through the Federally Facilitated Marketplace. Sarah is the former Assistant Coach for the Tri-Valley High School girls' soccer team, former President of the Zanesville Kiwanis Club, member of the Chamber's Convention & Visitors Bureau, council member of the Muskingum County Community Foundation, is a "Big Sister" for Big Brothers Big Sisters, a member of Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church and part of Leadership Muskingum class of 2016. Sarah currently resides in Zanesville with her husband, Ryan, daughter Cecilia, and black lab, Nora.
Jim Sr. founded McInturf Insurance in November of 1975. He is a graduate of Ohio University and has over 43 years of experience as an Independent Agent where he specializes in property liability insurance. Jim has also developed a niche in working with business owners and construction contractors. He is a member of Zanesville Rotary where he serves as Sargent of Arms and was Rotarian of the Year in 2013. He and his wife, Sally, have been married for 49 years, have three children and eight grandchildren. Jim is also the past President of the Board at Goodwill Industries and has served on various boards throughout the community, including Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church. Jim is an avid sports fan, especially of the Ohio State Buckeyes and the Cleveland Browns, Indians and Cavaliers.
John Pattison is a Zanesville native and has spent the last 30 years as an Independent Insurance Agent in Zanesville. Prior to that, he spent 16 years in the discount retail store business. He and his wife of 48 years, Connie, have 2 sons and 1 daughter. They are the grandparents of 5 grandsons. They feel they are very fortunate that all of their children and grandchildren live in the Zanesville area.
John is an experienced commercial and personal lines agent. John has specialized in handling contractors, understanding the intricacies of the contractor’s world of subcontractors, certificates of insurance, contracts and contract surety bonds. He is currently serving on the Hastings Mutual Insurance Co. Agent's Advisory Council.
John's past and current community service contributes to making Zanesville a great place to live and raise a family.
Youth League and Athletic Booster officer and coach
Middle School and High School girls reserve basketball coach
Past school board member and President of the West Muskingum School Board
School levy chairman and volunteer
Past President of the Zanesville Daybreak Rotary
Past Rotary Assistant District Governor
Active member in Zanesville Daybreak Rotary
Master Gardener Muskingum County
Board Member of the West Muskingum Academic Fund
Member Market St. Baptist ChurchJohn works hard to forge relationships with clients – giving them tangibility to something intangible.
Ray Fulmer, CLU CHFC LUTCF, is a graduate of Morgan High School and the American College. He began his insurance career with the Monumental Life Insurance Company in 1972. In 1994, Ray founded Fulmer Insurance Service, specializing in home, auto, business, life and annuities. Ray and his wife, Rose, have been married for 46 years, have 2 children and 2 grandchildren. Ray enjoys spending time in his RV traveling the country. He also enjoys racing as well as Ohio State football and basketball.
Nancy is originally from Cincinnati and a graduate of Xavier University with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration. She began her career as Director of Media for Blue Bell Ice Cream in Brenham, Texas where she coordinated the purchasing of radio, television and billboard advertising for over 250 radio and television stations in 5 states and 25 cities. After taking time off to raise her children, she found her niche helping Medicare aged individuals determine what best fits their insurance needs through Medicare Advantage Plans, Medicare Supplements, and/or Part D plans. She has been a licensed agent with McInturf-Fulmer Insurance Group since 2014, serving the Medicare population in Muskingum, Guernsey, Perry, and surrounding counties.
She has been a resident of Zanesville for 21 years with her husband, Tim. They have two daughters and two grandchildren. In her spare time, she loves to garden, paint, and spend time with her family.
Joyce started her career as a customer service representative in 1979 at the McInturf Insurance Agency. She then became a licensed property and casualty agent in 1984. Joyce has one son, one daughter, and four granddaughters. In her spare time, Joyce enjoys golfing and going for walks. Her favorite place to vacation is Nashville and enjoys shopping at Easton.
Mickey has been a customer service representative since 1980 at the McInturf Insurance Agency and continues her career at the McInturf-Fulmer Insurance Group. Mickey has been married to Donald Seevers for 16 years. She has a son, Brady, and a daughter-in-law, Allison, and is the proud grandparent to baby Mack. Mickey enjoys reading and shopping, and loves to vacation to Myrtle Beach in the fall.
Matthew is a graduate of Zanesville High School class of 2015. He is currently attending Ohio University, working on his bachelor’s in business. He enjoys daily exercise as one of his hobbies and spending time with his dog. He is also a big sports fan of The Cleveland Indians and The Ohio State Buckeyes.