Contact Us


Compare and Save On Your Health Insurance

McInturf-Fulmer Insurance is ready to help you choose a health plan that gives you the right balance of costs and coverage. We have access to all the plans available and can help you compare costs to find the right plan for your family and your budget.

Health Insurance Updates

As you may know, the individual health insurance marketplace is extremely unstable. In 2017, Anthem was the only carrier for majority of Southeastern Ohio. Medical Mutual offered plans in counties such as Licking and Franklin, but you were forced to stay in-network or risk having no coverage at all. It was a rough year for everyone, to say the least. Unfortunately, we do not foresee any improvements for 2018. Anthem announced that they are pulling out completely and will no longer offer individual plans next year. Medical Mutual will still offer plans in their service area, but are still restricting their network. For those whose only option was Anthem, the “new” option for 2018 is with Caresource.

Fortunately, McInturf Fulmer Insurance will continue to assist and enroll clients for 2018. The Individual Open Enrollment Period runs November 1st – December 15th. During this time, individuals may enroll in a plan. To obtain an individual quote, simply call 740-454-9793 or click on the “health insurance quote” button at the top of our website and fill out our secure quote form.*

For those who only need coverage for a couple months, we do offer Short-Term Medical Plans(STM). STM plans are a great way to have coverage for those periods of time between jobs or if you are turning 65 later in the year. If you are needing coverage for a few months out of the year, feel free to contact our office or simply browse our plans under “companies” using the “Pivot Health” link located at the bottom of the page. Individuals can purchase a STM any time during the year.

Needing dental or vision? We have multiple carriers to meet your needs. Simply contact us and provide your dentist/optometrist’s name, and we can verify the network for you. There is no enrollment period for dental or vision, you may enroll at any time. We also offer dental and vision for groups.

With everything that is happening in the individual marketplace, we highly encourage employers to entertain the idea of a group health plan. There are many carriers in the group marketplace and there is no enrollment period for a new group. As an added bonus, you do not have to deal with the headache of the individual marketplace. Carriers realize the uncertainty with Obamacare and have found ways to make group plans more affordable for employers. If you are an employer (including those who are self-employed), call or use our contact form to obtain a group health quote. There are new cost saving tools we can offer to groups; it would almost be a disservice to your employees to not explore these new cost saving tools. Call or email for more information.

Unhappy with your high deductible health plan? Let us quote an indemnity health plan for you and your family. Indemnity plans reimburse you for hospital stays, which is especially important for those who were unprepared or underinsured. We partner with companies who offer such plans to help you financially in times of need.

Feel free to contact our health/life agent, Sarah McInturf, for any of the above services at
*quoting fee may apply

Pivot Health ​Short Term Medical

Pivot Health Short Term Medical, administered by Allied National and underwritten by Companion Life, is designed to provide great short-term coverage with benefit options equivalent to long-term coverage, making it the perfect fit for you if you are:

  • In between jobs
  • Just starting a new job and waiting for coverage
  • A college student or recent graduate with no health coverage
  • Unable to qualify for or afford individual coverage or Cobra
  • Waiting for Exchange Open Enrollment

Helping you find the right solution

There are plenty of options but it is not easy finding the one that is right for you and your family. That is where McInturf-Fulmer insurance group can help assist you in finding the right plan at the right price.

Antehm Medicare Quote Medical Mutual of Ohio Medicare and Short-term quotes

As an independent agent, McInturf-Fulmer Insurance has access to an array of health insurance programs assuring you receive the most competitive options available. Use our online quote capabilities to compare and plan features and costs, or call us directly and speak with one of our experienced health insurance agents. We are prepared to help you find competitively priced plans based on your family and individual needs.

ACA "ObamaCare" Info and Enrollment Center

Our online tools and dedicated enrollment specialists will assist you in determining several important pieces of information to help you in your health care options and decision for 2016 coverage. We will determine if you are eligible for an Advanced Federal Premium Subsidy for your health insurance purchase. Then we will show you comparisons in both the subsidized Health Marketplace established by the Federal Government and Private 'exchange' insurance plans.
Get A Quote Now

Employer & Employee Administrative Services

Our brokers, group counselors and enrollment specialists will assist you in determining your obligations under the Affordable Care Act and a road map to keep you and your employees aware of your options through employer sponsored plans or worksite voluntary enrollment in health exchanges. In the absence of an employer sponsored group plan, we will be your resource to educate your employee about their personal options and federal subsidies to purchase compliant health insurance. We will enroll and service those policies issued to your employees.

Shop Now For Insurance Options

Health Plan Options

Health Plan Options

Under the Affordable Care Act you are required to Purchase health insurance for 2015. You may be eligible for a advanced federal premium subsidy which will be paid to the insurer you choose To offset the total monthly premium for your insurance you may also be eligible for a cost sharing subsidy to pay expenses required by your new health plan.
View Site

Dental & Vision

Dental & Vision

If you are in the market for dental and vision insurance and find yourself asking, -Why do I need it?- consider the advantages to your overall health. Our oral and ocular health can be key indicators in detecting early stages of many health risks and diseases along with preventing many other health issues.
View Site

Supplemental Health Insurance

Supplemental Health Insurance

We have many options and many providers to assist with your needs.
View Site

Employer Insurance

Employer Insurance

In 2016 your employees will be required to carry a qualified health plan or pay a penalty. While employer responsibility will depend on the number of full time employees you have, the workplace will still be the first place the working uninsured will seek information and help. There are direct and indirect benefits in 2016 to employers. HEMA and our partners are available to assist you in any way you decide to participate.
View Site

Site Links

Coverage Categories

Customer Service

Please note that NO changes to your policy or coverage are binding by submitting Online Forms & Requests. Change requests will only be considered bound upon confirmation from your Broker/Agent.