Your Best Policy
is a Good Agent

I Want To


Combined Years
of Experience







Insurance Services

Our dedicated & knowledgeable staff provides each client with the sales and service to meet their specific needs.

Coverage Options

Questions about Medicare?

Medicare can be very confusing. Between Part A, B, D, F, G…the list goes on! Fortunately, at McInturf Fulmer Insurance, we can assist you with the entire process. Whether it’s a Medicare Supplement, a Medicare Advantage plan, or a Prescription Drug Plan, we have the tools and resources to guide you through it all.

As independent agents, we work with a variety of plans and carriers to find the best product for you. A few carriers we represent include:

  • • Aetna
  • • Anthem
  • • Medical Mutual of Ohio
  • • Humana

The Annual Election Period is the time of year members can either make changes or enroll in a plan. The Annual Election Period takes place October 15th – December 7th.

For more information on Original Medicare, Medicare Supplements, Medicare Advantage Plans, or Prescription Drug Plans, please call us at 740-454-9793 or click on the “Medicare Quote” button at the top of our website and fill out our secure quote form.


2017 Dakota Matz Fitness Challenge

The McInturf Fulmer Insurance Group is a proud sponsor of the Dakota Matz Fitness Challenge.

Dakota is active in the local community focusing on fitness and personal welness.

In Our

McInturf-Fulmer Insurance Group believes in taking an active role in the community which we live and work in. It is through our community activity that we not only help those around us but also strengthen our relationships with other community members.

Our Team


What Our Customers Say

"Mike is a Professional Agent that I enjoy working with. He is committed to his customers and loyal to his company providers as well. He creatively works with his customers to develop an insurance program that fits all of their exposures. It is a pleasure to work with people like Mike!"

Recent Client
Leave Your Feedback

"God bless you. After all of the insurance companies we have dealt with, it seems you are the only one who is looking out for us. It is nice for a change. Thanks again. "

"Of course, I think of you first when someone needs an honest hard working knowledgeable agent...Thanks for helping!"

Satisfied Customer
Leave Your Feedback

Site Links

Coverage Categories

Customer Service

Please note that NO changes to your policy or coverage are binding by submitting Online Forms & Requests. Change requests will only be considered bound upon confirmation from your Broker/Agent.